Fremont Man Enters Plea in 2019 Branch County Amish Buggy Crash
Tuesday, May 11, 2021

COLDWATER, MI – A Fremont, man entered a no contest plea in a case involving an Amish buggy crash that happened in 2019.

During a Branch County Circuit Court session on Tuesday, 23-year-old Tyler Frye entered into a plea agreement for a charge of O.W.I. Causing Death. The plea was in connection to an Algansee Township crash in June of 2019, which took the lives of three children as well as a unborn child.

Michigan State Police said at the time of the incident, 6-year-old Lillian Graber, 4-year-old Moses Graber and 2-year-old Jacob Graber died after a pickup truck driven by Frye hit the back of their Amish horse-drawn carriage on Kelley Road south of Lester Road.

The mother of the fatal victims was pregnant and lost her baby. She along with another child were seriously injured.

According to the agreement filed, Frye will get a prison sentence of between 42 months and 15 years.
In exchange for Frye’s plea, all other charges will be dismissed by prosecutors.

A sentencing hearing has been scheduled for June 30.


(06-18-2021) • West Central Indiana Reports an Earthquake Thursday

(06-18-2021) • Tickets on Sale for Gordon Lightfoot Concert at Trine

(06-18-2021) • Michigan Opening To Full Capacity June 22

(06-18-2021) • Michigan Stepping Up Speed Enforcement During Regional Traffic Safety Campaign

(06-17-2021) • Sellbom Came to Tri-State for Football, Went on to Acclaimed Psychology Career

(06-17-2021) • May 2021 Jobless Rate Up Slightly In Michigan

(06-17-2021) • Hoosiers Feeding the Hungry Receive $5,000 to Aid in Hunger Relief

(06-17-2021) • Governor Holcomb Honors Businesses for Longevity, Service to Hoosier Workforce

(06-16-2021) • Whitmer To Use Unemployment Bonus As Back To Work Incentive

(06-16-2021) • Leisure and Travel-Related Industry Bouncing Back after COVID-19

(06-15-2021) • New TrineLine Podcast Reflects on School Year, Looks Ahead to the Fall

(06-15-2021) • Consumers Warned to Watch Out for Home Improvement Scammers

(06-15-2021) • INDOT Increases Starting Salary for Skilled Trades Positions

(06-14-2021) • Crash Between Two Motorcycles Injures Two People

(06-11-2021) • Former U.S. Sens. Evan Bayh, Dan Coats to join Indiana University

(06-11-2021) • Man Facing Murder Charges in Williams County, Ohio Tried Escaping Florida Maximum Security

(06-11-2021) • State Officials Closing OptumServ COVID Testing Sites; Other Local Remain Open

(06-11-2021) • MSP Says Stay Safe During Heat Wave

(06-11-2021) • Michigan Launches Text Message Program For COVID Information

(06-11-2021) • Trine Alumni & Friends Golf Outing coming Aug. 6th

>> News Archive